This page sets out what each text says, in its own words where we could read them, why later teachers think the rule exists, and what it means for a bowl of curd rice or raita at dinner. It describes a tradition. It is not medical advice, and it does not say that curd at night causes any illness.
What the Charaka Samhita says
The rule sits in the Charaka Samhita’s seventh chapter, Naveganadharaniya, the chapter on not suppressing natural urges (Sutrasthana 7). The verse begins “na naktam dadhi bhunjita”, one should not eat curd at night. In the translation on carakasamhitaonline.com, Sutrasthana 7.61 reads: “Curd should not be consumed at night. Otherwise, if curd is to be taken, it should be mixed with ghee, sugar, green gram soup, honey or amalaka. It should not be heated also.”
So the verse gives three rules: not at night, not heated, and not plain, but taken with one of five companions. The next verse, Sutrasthana 7.62, lists the illnesses the text says may follow when a person fond of curd ignores these rules. That list is the text’s teaching about its own time. No modern study has tested it, and we do not repeat it as a warning.
The same text describes curd itself in its chapter on food and drink (Sutrasthana 27, Annapanavidhi). Curd is called sour after digestion, hot in potency, nourishing and vata-reducing (Sutrasthana 27.225). Sutrasthana 27.227 says that curd is “generally prohibited in autumn, summer and spring seasons”, that is, in Sharad, Grishma and Vasanta. Sutrasthana 27.228 adds that curd which has not set properly disturbs all three doshas, while well-set curd reduces vata.
What the Ashtanga Hridayam says
The Ashtanga Hridayam, the later verse summary by Vagbhata, covers curd in its chapter on liquids (Sutrasthana 5). Verse 29 describes curd as sour in taste and after digestion, binding, heavy and hot, and says it reduces vata. Verse 30 lists what it increases, among them fat, strength, kapha, pitta, blood and the digestive fire, and says it gives relish for food.
Then come the rules. Verse 31 says “naivadyan nishi naivoshnam vasantoshnasharatsu na”: curd should not be eaten at night, not hot, and not in spring, summer or autumn. Verse 32 says it should not be eaten without green gram soup, honey, ghee, sugar candy or amalaki, not every day, and not before it has set properly. The verse numbers here are those of the siva.sh edition, which this site uses for the Ashtanga Hridayam on its tool pages.
The two texts agree closely. Vagbhata repeats Charaka’s night rule, his heating rule and his list of companions, and adds two more: not daily, and not half-set.
What the Sushruta Samhita adds
The Sushruta Samhita describes curd in its chapter on liquids (Sutrasthana 45), with a long section on curd from different animals and in different stages. At the close of that section it says “hemante shishire chaiva varshasu dadhi shasyate”: curd is recommended in early winter, late winter and the rains. In the parts of the section we read, we did not find a rule about night. So the night rule comes from Charaka and Vagbhata, and Sushruta’s contribution is the seasons in which curd suits.
Put together, the three texts say curd is a food for the cold and wet months, eaten by day, unheated, with something that balances it.
What about curd with sugar, buttermilk or raita?
Curd with sugar. Both texts name sugar among the companions that make curd acceptable, but the night rule is separate. Read plainly, Charaka (Sutrasthana 7.61) says curd is not to be eaten at night, and that when it is eaten it should be mixed with one of the five. Adding sugar answers the second rule, not the first.
Buttermilk. The texts treat buttermilk (takra) as a different food. The verse in the Ashtanga Hridayam right after the curd rules calls buttermilk light, astringent and sour, and says it stimulates digestion and reduces kapha and vata (Sutrasthana 5.33). The night rule is written for curd. Whether thin buttermilk at dinner is therefore fine is a teacher’s reading, not something the verses say. Our takra recipe gives the traditional midday drink.
Raita and curd rice. Raita, kadhi and curd rice are everyday dinner foods in many Indian homes, especially in the south. The texts’ rule and the custom of the kitchen differ here, and we do not suggest that a family meal is harmful. If you want to follow the classical rule, keep curd for the midday meal, which is also when our daily routine planner places the main meal of the day.
Heated curd. Both texts say curd should not be heated. Kadhi, which is cooked curd and gram flour, is a long-standing dish, and the texts do not name it. This is another place where custom and the verses part.
Curd with fruit, fish or milk
Curd also appears in the classical lists of incompatible foods, viruddha ahara. The Sushruta Samhita names curd among the things not to be taken with milk (Sutrasthana 20). Our viruddha ahara checker shows the verse and a quotation for each pair the texts name, and the food combining page explains the idea. These rules are separate from the night rule.
What modern research says
We searched PubMed, the US National Library of Medicine’s index of medical research, on 13 November 2026 for curd or dahi with night or evening in the title or abstract, and for yoghurt with night, bedtime or evening in the title. We found no study in people that compared eating curd or yoghurt at night with eating it by day. The papers returned were about dairy science and cheesemaking, and one about children’s sleep and yoghurt intake that did not test timing. So the night rule has not been tested. It has not been shown to be right, and it has not been shown to be wrong.
Plain curd is an ordinary part of a balanced diet in modern nutrition advice. Some people do feel heavy or get reflux after a large meal shortly before lying down, whatever the meal is, and an early, light dinner suits them. Our dinner time tool works out a dinner window from your city’s sunset, following the tradition’s rule of an early evening meal.