In short

By the classical texts, milk should not be taken with banana, mango, jamun or any sour fruit. The Charaka Samhita lists these among the fruits “antagonistic to milk” and adds that all sour foods are (Sutrasthana 26.84), and the Sushruta Samhita names banana with milk, curd or buttermilk, and mango and jamun with milk (Sutrasthana 20.13). So a banana shake or a mango shake is, in the texts’ terms, an incompatible combination. We found no study in people; one study in rats reported mild changes.

Start here

Educational, not medical advice. Herbs can interact with medicines and are not safe for everyone: see a qualified doctor for any health question.

Who should take care anyway

  • Milk allergy or lactose intolerance. These matter far more than any combination rule. Avoid milk or use a suitable alternative.
  • Diabetes. Fruit shakes with sugar or honey raise blood sugar quickly. Whole fruit and plain milk taken separately are easier to portion. Follow your doctor’s or dietitian’s advice.
  • Kidney disease. Banana, mango and milk all carry potassium or phosphorus, which may need limits. Follow your kidney dietitian.
  • Babies. No honey before one year, in shakes or anything else.
Read the full guide5 more sections: the background, the history and where it comes from

This page sets out what each text names, what it leaves out, and how to read the rule beside everyday Indian food. It describes a tradition and is not medical advice.

What the Charaka Samhita says

In its chapter on incompatible food (Sutrasthana 26, Atreyabhadrakapyiya), the Charaka Samhita gives a list of fruits that are not to be taken with milk. In the translation on carakasamhitaonline.com, as quoted by our viruddha ahara checker, it reads: “amra, amrataka, matulunga, nikucha, karamarda, mocha, dantashatha, badara, koshamra, bhavya, jambu, kapittha … these fruits and similar other substances, all sour liquids or non-liquids are antagonistic to milk.”

In everyday names, amra is the mango, mocha the banana and jambu the jamun. Later in the same chapter, sour things with milk are the text’s example of incompatibility by combination (Sutrasthana 26.99).

Two points are easy to miss. The list ends with “and similar other substances”, so Charaka meant it as examples, not a closed list. And the clearest general rule is about sourness: anything sour with milk.

What the Sushruta Samhita says

The Sushruta Samhita treats incompatible food in Sutrasthana 20. As our checker shows from the Sanskrit (verse 20.13 in Jadavji Trikamji Acharya’s edition), it names banana with palmyra fruit, milk, curd or buttermilk, and names mango and jamun with milk. Kunja Lal Bhishagratna’s English translation of 1907 runs part of this list together and leaves curd out of the banana line, which is why the checker follows the Sanskrit. Earlier in the chapter (verse 20.8), sour fruit is among the things not to be taken with milk.

So both texts agree on banana with milk, mango with milk, jamun with milk and sour fruit with milk.

What the texts do not say

  • They do not name every fruit. Apples, grapes, dates, pears, papaya and many others are not named in these two passages. “Not named” is not the same as “recommended”: it only means these verses do not list them, as our checker says for such pairs. Charaka’s “and similar other substances” leaves the door open.
  • They do not call it poison. The word is viruddha, incompatible, food that does not suit the body.
  • They give exceptions. Charaka says incompatibility is neutralised in people used to the food, in a small quantity, with strong digestion, in the young, and in people who are well oiled, who exercise and who are strong (Sutrasthana 26.106).

Charaka also lists eighteen kinds of incompatibility (Sutrasthana 26.86 to 87), by place, time, amount, preparation, order and more, so pairs of foods are only part of the idea. Our food combining page explains the wider teaching.

Banana shake, mango shake and fruit custard

These are everyday foods in Indian homes: banana milkshake for children, mango shake in summer, fruit custard at parties, strawberry or chikoo shakes in cafes. By the verses above, banana and mango shakes are named combinations, and a shake made with any sour fruit falls under Charaka’s sour rule. Fruit custard combines milk with several fruits, some of them named.

If you want to follow the tradition, the simplest steps are:

  • Eat fruit on its own, as a snack between meals, rather than blended into milk.
  • Keep sour fruit and milk apart, including lemon, orange, pineapple and sour berries.
  • Take milk on its own, warm; our golden milk recipe is one way.

If you do not follow the tradition, there is no human study showing that a banana shake is harmful. Charaka’s own exception for what the body is used to, in small amounts, suits a person who has drunk them for years without trouble.

What research says

We searched PubMed, the US National Library of Medicine’s index of medical research, on 13 November 2026 for banana, mango or fruit with milk together with viruddha or incompatible. Of the three papers it returned, one tested the combination: a 2021 study in the Journal of Ayurveda and Integrative Medicine that gave Wistar rats banana with cow’s milk for 28 days and reported some changes in blood tests (SGOT, urea and creatinine) and mild changes in heart, liver and spleen tissue, which its authors read as mild toxic effects. That is one study, in rats, and it has not been repeated in people. We found no study in people.

So the rule is an old teaching that modern research has barely tested. It has not been shown to be harmful in people, and it has not been shown to be safe.

Frequently asked questions

↳ Can we drink milk with banana according to Ayurveda?

The texts say no. The Charaka Samhita lists mocha, the banana, among fruits antagonistic to milk (Sutrasthana 26.84), and the Sushruta Samhita names banana with milk, curd or buttermilk (Sutrasthana 20.13). No study in people has tested it.

↳ Is mango shake bad according to Ayurveda?

Both texts name mango with milk as incompatible (Charaka Samhita, Sutrasthana 26.84; Sushruta Samhita, Sutrasthana 20.13). That is the tradition's teaching; it has not been tested in people.

↳ Which fruits can be taken with milk in Ayurveda?

The two passages we follow do not give a list of fruits that suit milk. They name some that do not, and Charaka adds all sour foods and "similar other substances". A fruit not named is simply not named, not approved.

↳ Why does Ayurveda say sour fruit and milk do not go together?

Charaka gives sour things with milk as his example of incompatibility by combination (Sutrasthana 26.99). The verses give the rule; they do not describe a mechanism, and none has been shown in research.

This page describes what classical texts say and is not medical advice. Please read the medical disclaimer, and speak to a doctor or registered dietitian about your diet.