More than 50 liver injury reports since 2017
LiverTox, in its monograph on Tinospora (guduchi), reports more than 50 cases of clinically apparent acute liver injury since 2017, many of them during the COVID-19 pandemic, when guduchi was being promoted as a way to boost immunity. Most were from India and Thailand, and there were single cases in Germany, Belgium, France and the United States.
The reported injury was typically hepatocellular, meaning it affected the liver cells themselves. It began from a few weeks to about six months after starting the herb. Autoantibodies were common, and biopsies often showed features of autoimmune liver disease. Several cases were fatal, most often in people who already had liver disease. In most others the liver recovered after the herb was stopped. The mechanism is not known, but it is thought to be immune mediated.
LiverTox gives guduchi a likelihood score of A, which is its category for a well-established cause of clinically apparent liver injury. That is the strongest rating the scheme has.
What this means in practice:
- Guduchi is not a harmless tonic. The reports involve capsules, tablets, juices and decoctions marketed for health.
- People with existing liver disease are the group at greatest risk of a bad outcome, and should avoid it unless a hepatologist agrees.
- Tiredness, nausea, poor appetite, dark urine or yellowing of the skin or eyes while using guduchi are reasons to stop and seek medical care promptly. These are the usual warning signs of liver trouble in general.
- Tell your doctor if you have used guduchi when you are given liver tests, since it may explain unexpected results.
Animal studies, the immunity claim and minor side effects
According to LiverTox, guduchi has been used in Ayurveda for many conditions, but the activities seen in animal studies have not been shown in humans. We are not going to repeat claims of immune boosting or of other benefits, because we found no support for them in the sources we checked. NCCIH has no page on guduchi, and describes research on Ayurvedic treatments generally as limited, with small and sometimes poorly designed trials.
Side effects listed as uncommon by LiverTox include headache, dizziness, nausea, abdominal discomfort, diarrhoea and rash.
Who should avoid guduchi, and medicine interactions
- Liver. Well established cause of liver injury, with fatal cases. See the first section. Avoid with existing liver disease.
- Pregnancy and breastfeeding. The sources we checked do not cover this, so we cannot confirm safety. Given the liver reports, please speak to a doctor before using any guduchi product at all.
- Children. Not covered by our sources. Ask a paediatrician, and do not give guduchi products to a child on your own judgement.
- Autoimmune conditions. LiverTox describes autoimmune features in the injury cases and an immune-mediated mechanism. We found no source that covers guduchi for people with autoimmune disease, so those people should ask their specialist before any use.
- Medicines. NCCIH notes that most herb-drug interactions in current sources are hypothetical and that narrow-margin medicines such as warfarin, digoxin and chemotherapy call for the most care. It does not name guduchi. Any medicine that itself affects the liver is a reason to ask a doctor or pharmacist before adding guduchi.
- Surgery. Tell your surgical team about any herbal product before an operation.
- Kidney and allergies. No source we checked covers these. Please ask a doctor if either applies.
- Contamination and labelling. NCCIH warns that some Ayurvedic preparations may contain lead, mercury or arsenic at toxic levels. Combined with the Tinospora mislabelling noted above, a product may not contain what it says.
Guduchi and neem are often sold together as “immunity” products. For neem, see our neem page, where the oil carries its own serious warning.
This page is education, not medical advice. Please read our medical disclaimer, see a doctor for any health concern, especially yellowing of the skin or dark urine, and a registered Ayurvedic practitioner (BAMS in India) for any Ayurvedic treatment.